fajrdrako: ([Lord of the Rings])


There was an interview with Christopher Tolkien, son of J.R.R. Tolkien, in LeMonde.

It was disappointingly superficial.

First off, I have little sympathy with Christopher Tolkien's viewpoint. I think that:

    (a) no author has control of his work after it is published - a right to royalties, yes, but what readers make of the work is their own choice, in the privacy of their own imaginations or in the cultural milieu. Christopher Tolkien seems to resent the playfulness of The Lord of the Rings which is part of its greater appeal.

    (b) I don't like to see anyone, least of all the Tolkien estate, bilked of their legal rights. I also do not approve of the descendants of an author receiving ongoing payment for a work after the original author is dead. Christopher Tolkien may have been an editor of the books, but he did not write them. It seems unjust to me that he should feel himself due profit from movies that he did not make, did not approve of, and which he attacks at every opportunity.

    (c) It seems to me from the quoted comments that if Christopher Tolkien had made a movie of Lord of the Rings it would be pedantic and boring. Makes me glad that Tolkien had already sold the rights. Didn't Christopher inherit any of his father's sense of humour and largesse?

    (d) It sounds as if Christopher has made a career out of being his father's son. He would have been better off developing his own career at Oxford. Or, given that he is the Tolkien Estate and could give himself permission, he could have have written his own works in Tolkien's worlds, rather than devoting himself to the endless eyestraining work on his father's papers.


fajrdrako: ([Bilbo Baggins])


[livejournal.com profile] maaseru, Pim and I had planned to go to see The Hobbit as soon as it opened, because, after all, The Lord of the Rings is among our very favourite books and movies and we feel a deep gratitude, love and loyalty to J.R.R. Tolkien and to Peter Jackson.

But when the time came, we hesitated, said "Let's go see Skyfall again instead," and did.

When I first read The Lord of the Rings when I was fourteen, full of a deep and endless passion for that book, I then turned to The Hobbit, hoping for more of the same. I was devastated to discover that it was too cute, too dull, too shallow - that it lacked everything I had loved about The Lord of the Rings and contained everything I hadn't loved about The Lord of the Rings.

I read it again about ten years ago, and thought it wasn't as bad as I remembered. I liked "Riddles in the Dark" and the "Conversation with Smaug". But Lord of the Rings it isn't.

So. Courage in hand, I went to see The Hobbit today, with Tasia, StarWolf, and Chrystine. It got off to a bad start: the first ten minutes of the movie were badly out of focus, with or without the 3D glasses. I couldn't tell what was going on, and was starting to feel queasy from trying. They sorted that out about the time Gandalf got to Bag End, so that was all right.

In the end, I thought the movie was 95% boring and 5% brilliant, and the intense brilliance of a few choice moments made the rest of it worthwhile.

The great moments? They were... )

fajrdrako: (Bilbo Baggins)


I just watched this: the trailer to the coming Peter Jackson movie, The Hobbit.

Aiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiieeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.

It made me cry a little. And I never even liked The Hobbit, or Bilbo Baggins, either. Now I love him. Oh my goodness. Peter Jackson and Martin Freeman between them have done the impossible.

fajrdrako: ([Lord of the Rings])




I have a plan to use different wallpaper for each month of the year, and for Frebruary I wanted to use one of the drawings by Alan Lee that we see with the closing credits for The Return of the King. Remember them? They looked like this.

Well, I can't find any of these suitable for wallpaper anywhere online. Anyone have any ideas how to find them? If I bought The Lord of the Rings Sketchbook are they included?

fajrdrako: ([Lord of the Rings])




Day 30 - Your favorite movie of all time

A difficult choice. I wanted to say The Music Man; I often say it's The Lion in Winter; but for a host of reasons, I'm going to have to say The Lord of the Rings. Why?

  1. A beautiful adaptation of one of my favourite books. They actually appreciated the use of language, and made the most of it.
  2. Great casting, especially Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn and Sean Bean as Boromir. And just about everyone else. Hugo Weaving as Elrond? That was inspired.
  3. The movie made me love Faramir.
  4. Best costuming I've ever seen. The embroidery on Gandalf's gown. The tailoring of Elrond's robes. Eomer's armour.
  5. "I would have followed you into the very fires of Mordor."
  6. Beautiful scenery, making the whole world want to visit New Zealand. Best of all, everything looked as it should. Especially Hobbiton, Rivendell, and Edoras. And Minas Tirith, especially the Great Hall.
  7. "For Frodo." There are some lines that always make me cry. And I've seen it... how many times?
  8. Pippin was done right.
  9. The Nazgul were actually scary.
  10. The death of Boromir.


fajrdrako: (Default)


Went to Costco with [livejournal.com profile] maaseru and bought nothing. Nothing! Very proud of myself. Well, I did eat a hot dog.

Baked a carrot cake from scratch. That was fun, particularly the cream cheese icing. It was a birthday cake for [livejournal.com profile] josanpq, whose birthday was last week.

Then [livejournal.com profile] josanpq came over and she and I and [livejournal.com profile] maaseru and [livejournal.com profile] maaboroshi and I all played the Lord of the Rings edition of Trivial Pursuit. It turned out to be very funny and sometimes goofy and often challenging. Some questions are absurdly easy and some not - for instance, I got, "What was the name of Theoden's niece?" followed by "What was the name of Arwen's horse?" Sometimes we thought the answer on the card was wrong - for instance, it said that only Gandalf had been to the Mines of Moria before The Fellowship of the Ring, but surely Aragorn had been there, too? [livejournal.com profile] maaboroshi really impressed us by knowing that it was October 24 when Frodo woke up in Rivendell; she confessed it was because that is her brother's birthday. Then I got the question of "What time of day was it?" I threw up my hands in despair.

Whenever Haldir's name came up we shouted "Shiny!" because he's a favourite (and oh so shiny).

[livejournal.com profile] maaboroshi won the game. I came second. The budgies ran a running commentary. They seemed to enjoy the game, too.

Over supper, we watched the third episode of Merlin. It didn't seem as slashy as the first two, but was fun anyway.

I didn't finish the story I'm working on, though, and tomorrow it looks as if I'll have no time at all.

fajrdrako: ([Misc])


This evening, I watched the movie Ringers: Lord of the Fans with [livejournal.com profile] maaseru and [livejournal.com profile] maaboroshi. It's a movie about Lord of the Rings fandom; they were making it when we went to the "Gathering" in Toronto.

And it was very entertaining. I'm not sure if there was anything there that I didn't already know, but it was a nice overview of how Tolkien's works have been regarded over the years. Some of it was nostalgic and some of it was funny - like Leonard Nimoy's Ballad of Bilbo Baggins.

Oh yes, there was an item I've never heard of - a place in California called Hobbiton, with a low-tech recreation of Frodo's journey.

Favourite bits: the interviews with Coleen Doran, Ian McKellen, Terry Pratchett, and David Carradine. It felt a little odd when I realized how many people in this movies I've actually met, one way or another - I should have kept a running count. This is what happens when you spend your life going to cons of one type or another.

fajrdrako: ([Torchwood] - John)


Spent the day watching The Lord of the Rings (extended edition) with [livejournal.com profile] maaseru, [livejournal.com profile] maaboroshi and [livejournal.com profile] lmondegreen. Because of all the snow, [livejournal.com profile] josanpq couldn't make it - drat! - but she phoned.

It's a wonderful New Year's Day tradition.

Sauron has fallen and all's right with the world.

fajrdrako: (Default)


In my last LJ entry I listed five favourite deaths from books and comics and then said, I can't think of any deaths in movies or television that would come even close.

I am an idiot. Or at least... I have a bad fannish memory.

The death of Boromir in the movie version of The Lord of the Rings: the Fellowship of the Ring gets me every time.

fajrdrako: ([Doctor Who] - Tree)
I got this quiz from [livejournal.com profile] kikibug13, To which race of Middle Earth do you belong? I didn't quite get the result I expected. I was angling for Gondorian. This would be second best - and they quote my favourite passage of Tolkieneque Anglo-Saxon poetry.Read more... )

This gets me thinking of The Wanderer, which is my favourite bit of Anglo-Saxon poetry, and the only one I have memorized in the original (in part) from an old Caedmon record that was in the public library when I was a teen:
Hwær cwom mearg? Hwær cwom mago?
Hwær cwom maþþumgyfa?
Hwær cwom symbla gesetu?
I had a translation... )

Yeah, I guess the Rohirrim might be the right place for me. Even if I was sort of dreaming of a Gondorian library of leather-bound books, with Romanesque arches overlooking a splendid vista...

Read more... )

fajrdrako: (Default)


For the past two years, I've been following a New Year's Day tradition with [livejournal.com profile] maaseru, [livejournal.com profile] maaboroshi and [livejournal.com profile] lmondegreen. We watch The Lord of the Rings. All of it. Extended edition. It takes about 12 hours. It's terrific fun. We compare favourite bits. We gasp or cry or complain when appropriate. [livejournal.com profile] maaseru asked us what our favourite line from the movie was. She said "Not this day," which is wonderful. I rather like "For Frodo", which is not much later. I also like "My brother, my captain, my king." For obvious (sniff) reasons.

Last night, we played The Lord of the Rings Trivial Pursuit as a sort of warm-up. I always confidently expect [livejournal.com profile] maaboroshi to win, but she didn't. I did. Wow. Would we generally have done better if we'd played the game after seeing the movie again today? Maybe, our memories would have been refreshed, but I don't know if it would have made much difference.

Today was my first day on my own with my new Monday workout. I couldn't remember what two of the weight exercises were like - or which was which - so I'll have to ask Lynne. It went pretty well. Day one of my New Year's Resolutions feels like a success. Haven't flossed yet. Have I given anything away? Hmm, no. Will do that before going to bed.

I love Aragorn as much as ever.

Profile

fajrdrako: (Default)
fajrdrako

October 2023

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
151617181920 21
22 232425262728
293031    

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 14th, 2025 01:33 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios