I just went and looked at
fannish5, and this week's question means nothing to me, but I realize I missed last week's. This week's item is
Name 5 remakes that never should have been made. I find that kind of meaningless... the world is full of movies that should never have been made; but on the whole, I've seen a number of remakes I've liked - more than that I have disliked, probably because in most cases I've seen the remake but not the original. I did like the later versions of
The Lion in Winter and
Born Yesterday, for example. I even liked the American movie
Shall We Dance? as well as the (admittedly better) Japanese version.
I just don't have any problem with remakes. I like seeing the same material from different points of view, or done in different styles. How many versions have I see of movies based on one of my favourite novels,
Jane Eyre? I hated some of them and have loved one of them and liked at least one more - I'm glad they kept remaking it, and I hope they continue to do so.
This week:
What are your five favorite instances of amnesia, in canon or fan fiction?Until recently I'd have probably said I didn't like any amnesia stories. I know of none I like in fan fiction; I'm open to recommendations. But in canon... well!
- In Doctor Who: Captain Jack lost two years' worth of memories, and resents it, and wants them back.
- In Torchwood, Captain Jack has invented Retcon, the drug that gives people selective amnesia, and he administers it wantonly and ruthlessly. I love the irony,the contradiction.
- in The Game of Kings by Dorothy Dunnett, near the beginning, Francis Crawford of Lymond is hit on the head and temporarily forgets his own identity, while a prisoner in the custody of Christian Stewart. There is some lovely banter through this chapter; a sense that Lymond can be himself as we seldom see him, because for once he has been able to forget his troubles. Sometimes I have wondered to what extent he was faking it. Sometimes I have wondered at various implications of the section. But I do love it.
- Brat Farrar, by Josephine Tey. I liked the TV movie based on the book, too.
- I can't think of a #5... give me time, here....