Happy Mother's Day...
May. 10th, 2009 02:33 pmHappy Mother's Day to all of you who are mothers, and who have mothers, or have ever had mothers.
As a Mother's day Tribute I was going to list my ten favourite fictional mothers. So I did that. I had some trouble thinking of ten fictional mothers at all. Most protagonists are not mothers. Most protagonists do not have mothers, or if they do, they're like Stephanie Plum's mother - hardly central to the action. Granma Mazure is more fun, but she's in a grandmother role. Grandmother's get to be cool and funny. Mothers, when funny, tend to be irritating.
IMDB did a list of "beloved TV moms", and of the list, I have only seen one of them, and I have mixed feelings about her: Joyce Summer on Buffy. She has some great moments, but also too many bad ones. (I haven't forgiven her for trying to break up Buffy and Angel at the end of season 3.)
So if you want to hear my initial list of mothers:
- Sarah Connor - Trained her kid to be an outlaw and machine-killer, but in a good cause. Great action hero.
- Sybilla Crawford - Some Dunnett readers think Sybilla is the worst mother of all time, warping and abusing her child, and never telling him the truth that might have saved him. Personally, I think Sybilla is great, especially in The Game of Kings.
- Eleanor of Aquitaine - Mother of the most dysfunctional brood of Plantagenets! "What family doesn't have its ups and downs?" Her fictionality is arguable, but I'm thinking of fictional depictions.
- Lady Macduff - a small role, but delightfully maternal.
- Martha Kent - I loved her in season one of Smallville. Not so much in later seasons.
- Mystique - she tried to kill Kurt in infancy, but was good to Rogue, in an evil-supervillain-mother sort of way.
- Cordelia Naismith - maybe the best mother ever, especially in Barrayar, in which she fights a war to save her damaged unborn child.
- Kate Somerville - One of my favourite characters ever, on any scale. A Dunnett character in her own right, as well as being Philippa's mother.
- Sue Richards - of the Fantastic Four. A character who has suffered from many bad writers, but who has had good moments, too. She has never quite overcome the problem of being the token female in the group, but I've always had a soft spot for her.
- Jackie Tyler - Rose Tyler's mum. I love her for so many reasons, not least because she once slapped the Doctor's face for Rose's sake. I maybe love her best in "Love and Monsters".
Only two of these women are the protagonists in their own story - Sarah Connor and Cordelia Naismith - and they both cede way to their sons as protagonists in a longer series. Most are minor character in a larger picture.
Thinking harder, I came up with a few more names. Jane Eyre? I wasn't too crazy over her attitude to Adèle, but she was a conscientious caretaker - this hardly puts her into a 'favourite mother' status.
Amanda from Star Trek. What a wonderful mother.
Jessica Jones, mother of Luke Cage's kid. The Wikipedia article on her here seems a little out of date.
Aunt May from Spider-Man.
Maria Von Trapp in The Sound of Music, and Donna Sheridan in Mamma Mia!.
And on a spoiler note, isn't it wonderful that