I have to agree that it did sour the ending for me as well.
It was one of three things that soured the ending for me, and neither was the Titantic crash scene.... Though I'm still trying to picture the TARDIS as an iceburg and it doesn't quite work. Why did the Titanic crash bother you?
That aside, my problems all centred on Jack: - the implication that the Doctor is no longer of central importance to Jack (I can rationalize this, but it's despite the text, not because of it) - the Doctor breaking the Vortex Manipulator - what right did he have to do that? - the Face of Boe joke
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
timeasmymeasure
no subject
Date: 2007-10-19 08:15 pm (UTC)It was one of three things that soured the ending for me, and neither was the Titantic crash scene.... Though I'm still trying to picture the TARDIS as an iceburg and it doesn't quite work. Why did the Titanic crash bother you?
That aside, my problems all centred on Jack:
- the implication that the Doctor is no longer of central importance to Jack (I can rationalize this, but it's despite the text, not because of it)
- the Doctor breaking the Vortex Manipulator - what right did he have to do that?
- the Face of Boe joke