One of my favourite kinds of comic books is the autobiographical graphic novel. There have been a number that I have loved:
The Spiral Cage by Al Davison, about living with spina bifida;
Melody by Sylvie Rancourt, about being a stripper in a Montreal;
Barefoot Gen, about a boy living in Hiroshima during World War II; and the works of
Harvey Pekar.
The Alcoholic isn't
quite that, since author Jonathan Ames hasn't identified it at autobiography. Fiction, then, telling a very personal story in which the protagonist has the same name and profession as the author, and who is drawn by the artist, Dean Haspiel, to look remarkably like the author as well.
Published (rather surprisingly) by Vertigo, it's the story of an American boy, Jonathan, growing up in a middle-class family, going to high school, where he becomes a weekend binge drinker with his friend Sal. His parents die; he becomes a mystery writer; he becomes obsessed with a girl who doesn't want him but still strings him along; he goes into rehab and out again, and he never quite manages to sort himself out. He never has a sense of belonging; he never feels
quite good enough. Unless he drinks, or does drugs. But then he always comes down again. And his life
takes one weird turn after another.

The part I liked best, sad though it was, was his friendship with a boy named Sal. Sal was Jonathan's best and only friend during high school. One night when drunk, they had sex. The next day, Jonathan was thinking how much he'd liked it, and was getting up the nerve to say "let's do it again" when Sal said, "Let's forget what happened last night. It was a mistake... Let's never talk about it again." So they didn't talk about it, and after a while, Sal started avoiding Jonathan, wouldn't return his calls... and Jonathan missed him dreadfully for years, always wondering what he'd done wrong.
Then years later, he ran into Sal, and they talked about it. Jonathan apologized for every possible wrong he could have done, and Sal said it was nothing like that at all. "I was in love with you. I could tell you were more into girls... I didn't want to wreck you." Avoiding Jonathan was the only way Sal knew of to deal with his feelings.
Then once again Sal avoids Jonathan's calls and won't see him. Much later, Jonathan hears from a mutual friend that Sal has gone back to Illinois, where he is dying of AIDS. His parents tell Jonathan that Sal is too ill for a visit or to talk on the phone, so Jonathan resolves to write to him. But every letter he begins seems wrong - he doesn't know what he wants to say, and in the end, Sal dies before Jonathan can write his letter.
The really sad part was that it was clear Jonathan loved Sal from the beginning.
Anecdotes and random scenes of Jonathan's life tend to focus on how self-conscious and ill at ease he feels, torn up by anxiety and loneliness. The only person he is close to is his rather charming nonagenarian great-aunt, who loves him but can't fix him. He always hid his drinking problem from his family.
Autobiography or fiction, it's an interesting and insightful book that beautifully illustrates a broken life, without offering solutions. It ends with Jonathan having a personal epiphany: "No one gets everything they want in life." And a resolve: "I will never drink again." He has resolved this many times before. There he stands, hesitant, in front of a bar advertising Happy Hour. Will he go in?
We can only guess.