Oct. 21st, 2007

fajrdrako: (Default)


Several people sent me links to this article about J.K. Rowling, about her announcement that Dumbledore was gay.

Now, until I read the final Harry Potter novel, Dumbledore was my least favourite character in the series.1 But after reading Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows I came to quite like Dumbledore - he turned out to be well aware of the failings I'd been condemning him for, so I easily forgave him.

My first thought: I wish she'd made the announcement about Sirius Black and Remus Lupin. That would have meant a lot more to me. Though admirable, Dumbledore was old, and not one of the characters for readers to identify with. It isn't so rare... )

My second thought: wasn't it pretty clear in the text, anyway? Maybe not quite spelled out. As so many things weren't.

My third thought: Even if it does feel to me, uncharitably, to be a case of: too little, too late, at least Rowling's heart is basically in the right place.

~ ~ ~

i Not quite true: I liked Ron Weasley much less.

fajrdrako: (Default)


[livejournal.com profile] silverwhistle sent me a link to a very interesting interview with Russell T. Davies by Stuart Jeffries. I'm miffed with the man for what he did with Captain Jack in the last Doctor Who episode "The Last of the Time Lords", but reading the interview makes me love him all over again. It's just as well I don't demand perfect judgement in my authors - even if I reserve my right to complain loudly and hold a grudge. I suppose my real issue is that I don't trust him as I did.

My favourite bit is near the beginning:
Russell T Davies was at a wedding recently when a guest complained about what he'd done to Doctor Who, an otherwise wholesome family drama. "She told me she was shocked because Captain Jack is bisexual and wouldn't let her children watch it," says Davies. "I had such a go at her. I said: 'You're an unfit mother. You're ignorant. Your children are cleverer than you.' Then her husband came up and I thought there was going to be a fight, but they left."
Then he says:
"The only place I don't like the attention is in gay clubs." You don't strike me as the least Garboish. "Oh, but I am. I love to watch the ghetto come to life - all those people from Tesco and Barclays becoming themselves at night. But I do miss my privacy. God knows what it must be like for David Tennant."
This brought mental images from Queer as Folk to mind - "people from Tesco and Barclays." Do gay people change more than others from their daytime working persona to their recreational time? I don't think so, but the difference might be more striking to those who have made untrue assumptions about them. Either way. I suspect that for every gay man whose personal life is more outrageous and colourful than his coworkers imagine, there is another whose life is as traditional and staid as you can imagine. Dishwashing, watching TV, and walking the dog rather than gay clubs and outre sex.
"What I've often done is to construct invented families where the bonds are better than natural ones." Is that a gay writer's thing - it does sound a tad Armistead Maupin. "Probably. It's not often self-conscious; usually I just have an instinct that these invented families make better stories.
Isn't that just the sign of the times? It isn't only gay people who invent their families. Many of the straight people I know are divorced, or single, or in long-distance relationships, or otherwise living in ways people did not live a century ago.
."Now there are children called gay teenagers and I hate them." Why? "Pure jealousy. I never came out at school and so missed out on the snogging and dry-humping. I, like most of my gay contemporaries, had 10 damaging years where we didn't do all that adolescent fumbling - that's why there's still such a sexual frenzy for gay men in their 20s."
I can relate. I'm ten years older than Davies and when I was a teen - coming out wasn't even an issue. Wasn't even (as far as I knew) a phrase. I knew I was bisexual before I knew there was a word for it. (Was I naive?) What's a teen to do with that? Not much they can do, and I'm not talking about snogging opportunities1, but identity issues. The teen years are notoriously difficult for everyone, but I look at the resources and support groups and public knowledge on the issue now, and yes, I'm jealous. It still isn't easy to 'be yourself' but now it's at least possible.
When I ask what he gets up to with his long-time partner, Andrew Smith, a customs officer, he says: "We watch TV and laugh loads. We don't live together, just see each other at weekends. I'm very lucky to have found someone who will tolerate that arrangement. If I'm writing, I would walk over his body if he had a heart attack."
This strikes me as incredibly endearing.
Davies is already planning a project to fill the Time Lord's 2009 gap year. It is a series codenamed MGM (More Gay Men). "It's going to be about fortysomething gay men and how jealous they are of gay teenagers."
Clearly the man is into autobiography!



~ ~ ~
1 Which, I admit, would have been nice.
fajrdrako: (Default)


I have talked before about my iffy relationship with Jane Austen and her books. Tonight [livejournal.com profile] maaseru and I watched the 2007 version of my favourite Austen novel, Persuasion. I always think that Austen had a good sense of irony but little or no sense of romance, and this novel is the one exception, where the hopeless faithful love of Anne Elliot and Captain Wentworth never fails to melt my heart.

This very much had the spirit of Jane Austen and the times, and I certainly enjoyed it - but still have criticisms and quibbles. I thought Anne was a little too nervous and mousy: she should be quiet and reserved, but her competence and her intelligence should still be abundantly clear. She is the backbone of the family. Likewise, the story is Persuasion, not Cinderella and still less Jane Eyre, and I Anne should not be quite so dowdily dressed at all times. The other women were wearing the lovely gowns of the Regency period; Anne was wearing drab upholstery.

Loved Alice Krige as Lady Russell, but I always love Alice Krige. Anthony Head was nicely obnoxious as Anne's vain father. Another familiar face from Doctor Who was Finlay Robertson, who played Captain Benwick here; he was Larry Nightingale in "Blink".

And Rupert Penry-Jones as Captain Wentworth.... He was nice to look at, and I kept thinking of him as a Georgette Heyer hero, with his good features and stylish hair. I wish he were a Georgette Heyer hero, I'm dying to see those novels filmed. But he was more a Darcy than a Wentworth - I couldn't quite believe that this man had spent the last eight years as Captain of a warship fighting the French. He seemed to have no life beyond his dialogue. He ought to have been an Edward Pellew type, but I couldn't imagine him shouting orders from the quarterdeck.

This movie also had the slowest kiss I have ever seen in cinema. Ludicrously so, when it should have been romantic.

So... it was good enough, and did justice to the story, but I preferred the 1995 version with Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds. That version also had one of my favourite put-down scenes of all time, when Sam West (as Mr. William Elliot)1 says to Anne, "Have you considered my marriage proposal?" and she replies, "I'm afraid I have had no time to give it any thought at all."2

~ ~ ~

1 It occurred to me while watching tonight that his name is Billy Elliot. Wrong connotation.

2 Not an exact quote. I'm going to have to watch again to catch it - not a hardship. I don't think it's in the book.

Profile

fajrdrako: (Default)
fajrdrako

October 2023

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
151617181920 21
22 232425262728
293031    

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 1st, 2025 12:02 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios